Unsurprisingly, even with the insurgent candidates added to its board last year, ExxonMobil recommends votes against all of the shareholder proposals on its proxy this year, including proposals on plastic production, scenario analysis, low carbon production, political spending, and executive perquisites. We recommend votes in favor of all of these proposals. But we have to agree with the board’s opposition to a proposal from tobacco and climate change disinformation disseminator Steven Milloy to prevent precatory proposals from shareholders.