Supplemental Comment Letter to SEC on Shareholder Proposals

A group of investors has filed a supplemental comment with the SEC asking for withdrawal of the proposed rule restricting shareholder proposals. The full comment is below. An excerpt: This evidence demonstrates that the economic harm that the amendments could cause if they were finalized far outweighs the de minimis purported benefits cited in the…

Shareholder Proposals Shaking Up Shareholder Say

First, shareholder power related proposals in American companies are essentially closing the gap in substantive shareholder power that existed between the United States and Europe. In the past fifteen years, shareholders have successfully made proposals in individual American corporations to de-stagger the board, to elect directors by majority instead of plurality vote, to allow shareholders…

A Successful Season for SASB-Based Shareholder Resolutions

Timed to the 2020 Annual General Meeting (AGM) season, shareholder advocacy non-profit As You Sow filed seven shareholder resolutions, on behalf of individual proponents, that specifically requested material disclosure compliant with environmental and social corporate reporting standards published by the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB). SASB standards are explicitly designed to reflect financially material aspects…

Supplemental Comments on SEC Proposed Rules: Proxy Advisors and Shareholder Proposals

ValueEdge Advisors has submitted two more supplemental comments on the SEC’s proposed rules on proxy advisory firms and shareholder proposals. We are grateful to James McRitchie for giving us permission to include his excellent research on the support for governance-related shareholder proposals. The full text of both comments are linked below. SEC supplemental comment on…

ISS: 2020 Climate Policy Proxy Voting Guidelines

ISS has released its new climate policy recommendations for voting proxies. The full text is below. An excerpt: Sustainability Reporting The concept of sustainability is commonly understood as meeting the needs of the present generation without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Indeed, the term sustainability is complex and poses…

Shareholder Proposals 2019—ESG No-Action Letter Trends and Strategies

Shareholder proposals relating to ESG matters are frequent targets for exclusion by companies, and based upon a survey of the no-action letters submitted during the 2019 proxy season, this trend continues. Over 40% of the no-action letters we reviewed for the 2019 proxy season related to a variety of ESG matters, and the arguments and…

SEC’s proxy proposal: Who would benefit? – MSCI

Ric Marshall of MSCI writes: The SEC is considering a proposed rule that would curb the ability of small individual investors — so-called “nuisance investors” — to propose shareholder resolutions on corporate proxies. We found that many proposals authored by small individual investors won substantial support from 2015 through 2019. More than half of all…